In the addiction community, there are two types of “recovery.” One is abstinence-based (completely abstaining from all drugs and alcohol) and one is harm-reduced based (drinking or using in moderation, or at least, in a safer environment than one is used to). Coming from a background in 12-Step, I always firmly believed in abstinence only. I never once believed an addict could use in moderation because, in time, they would eventually relapse. I actually still do believe this to an extent, however, not as passionately and vehemently as I used to. I think it’s different for everybody. My husband, a former cocaine addict, went to rehab once and never went back. He’s been clean from drugs for almost 20 years. He doesn’t believe he could ever use cocaine in moderation, hence being clean, however, he has used marijuana and alcohol since getting out of rehab when he was in high school. It didn’t lead him back to cocaine, nor did it turn him into a habitual pot smoker or alcoholic. As for me, I believed I needed to abstain completely from my eating disorder because it was too easy for me to play around with ED behaviors. After all, my husband doesn’t need cocaine to live, but I certainly need food to survive.
With that said, what I’m engaging in right now is harm reduction. I’m not abstaining from eating disorder behaviors, but I’m limiting them in hopes of maintaining my good health and emotional well-being. My ultimate goal is to still lose weight, but I can’t pretend like harm reduction fixes everything. I may not be constantly bingeing or weighing, I may not be constantly isolating or snapping at my husband, but I am still hiding a scale in my pajama drawer and eating almost 1,000 calories below my agreed caloric intake when I said I was beginning recovery again back in November of 2011.
I’m practicing harm reduction, the very same thing I preach to my clients to avoid. Is an alcoholic who moderately drinks really in recovery? Is an OxyContin addict who kicks his habit by visiting a methadone clinic every morning really in recovery? Is a heroin addict who goes into a clinic that offers clean needles really in recovery? Or are they just masking problems under the fact that they are “managing” their addictions? After all, if our lives really are good, there should be no reason to continue the self-destructive behavior, even if it is in moderation. Is harm reduction just an easy excuse to continue to get high or drunk? And given the fact that addiction is apparently genetically pre-disposed, can someone really use their drug of choice in moderation or will their brains eventually take over and do them in again?
I don’t believe what I’m doing is right. I believe to be truly free and happy, I must surrender all ED behaviors. But at the same time, I can see myself living the rest of my life like this. As long as I maintained my weight (Goal of 14 range BMI), ate enough to limit binges, felt relatively normal and happy, and no longer had compulsions, why not? Logically I know why not, but that’s what my brains says every day when I’m questioning when this will all end. Will I die from this? Will I survive until I’m 80 like this? Will I ever feel as connected to OA like I did a year ago? Will I ever go back? Will I ever eat normally again? Will I ever go into treatment? For today I’m practicing harm reduction, and it’s something I don’t necessarily agree with. How is that even possible? I guess as long as it keeps my eating disorder alive, I will agree to anything.
EDIT: Also want to add in that this whole relapse started with a safe, healthy diet. I lost weight slowly and safely. So in my own way, I was “using in moderation” and eventually relapsed. Harm reduction, as nice as it sounds, just doesn’t work, at least for me. As I said before, I think to be truly “free,” I need to abstain completely, or as best as I can.